Pitre T, Kiflen M, Helmeczi W, et al. The Comparative Effectiveness of Vasoactive Treatments for Hepatorenal Syndrome: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis. Crit Care Med. 2022 Jul 1. pii: 00003246-990000000-00020. doi: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000005595.
Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Hepatorenal syndrome (HRS) is associated with high rates of morbidity and mortality. Evidence examining commonly used drug treatments remains uncertain. We assessed the comparative effectiveness of inpatient treatments for HRS by performing a network meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials (RCTs).

DATA SOURCES: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Medline In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, Scopus, and Web of Science from inception.

STUDY SELECTION AND DATA EXTRACTION: Pairs of reviewers independently identified eligible RCTs that enrolled patients with type 1 or 2 HRS. Pairs of reviewers independently extracted data.

DATA SYNTHESIS: We assessed risk of bias using the Cochrane tool for RCTs and certainty of evidence using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations approach. Our main outcomes are all-cause mortality, HRS reversal, and serious adverse events. Of 3,079 citations, we included 26 RCTs examining 1,736 patients. Based on pooled analysis, terlipressin increases HRS reversal compared with placebo (142 reversals per 1,000 [95% CI, >87.7 to >210.9]; high certainty). Norepinephrine (112.7 reversals per 1,000 [95% CI, 52.6 to >192.3]) may increase HRS reversal compared with placebo (low certainty). The effect of midodrine+octreotide (67.8 reversals per 1,000 [95% CI, <2.8 to >177.4]; very low) on HRS reversal is uncertain. Terlipressin may reduce mortality compared with placebo (93.7 fewer deaths [95% CI, 168.7 to <12.5]; low certainty). Terlipressin probably increases the risk of serious adverse events compared with placebo (20.4 more events per 1,000 [95% CI, <5.1 to >51]; moderate certainty).

CONCLUSIONS: Terlipressin increases HRS reversal compared with placebo. Terlipressin may reduce mortality. Until access to terlipressin improves, initial norepinephrine administration may be more appropriate than initial trial with midodrine+octreotide. Our review has the potential to inform future guideline and practice in the treatment of HRS.

Ratings by Clinicians (at least 3 per Specialty)
Specialty Score
Gastroenterology
Intensivist/Critical Care
Hospital Doctor/Hospitalists
Internal Medicine
Nephrology
Comments from MORE raters

Hospital Doctor/Hospitalists rater

New insight into treatment of HRS is provided by the robustly conducted network meta-analysis. At a minimum, this should raise questions regarding the practice of deferring to octreotide + midodrine as the preferred first-line therapy in many practices.

Internal Medicine rater

An interesting study that compares terlipressin with both noradrenaline and mitodrine and octreotide in cases of HRS. would like to add the following comment:Continuous intravenous infusion of terlipressin is effective at lower doses than those required for intravenous bolus doses.

Internal Medicine rater

Almost all of us knew about the beneficial effect of terlipressin in hepatorenal syndrome, but we did not have enough evidence to support it. Despite the study design, this study is very useful for showing that terlipressin is superior to any other vasoactive agent in hepatorenal syndrome.

Nephrology rater

Treatment of HRS is not well defined according to cumulated knowledge. This meta-analysis could help to select therapy.